Facebook Twitter Instagram
    Reading Time
    • Home
    • Reviews
      • Highly Recommended
      • CBCA Short Listed
      • Early Childhood Books
      • Younger Readers
      • Intermediate Readers
      • Older Readers
      • ANZAC books
      • Great Read Alouds
      • Information Books
      • LGBTQIA+
      • Picture Books
      • Professional Development
    • Interviews
    • Suggestions
    • News
    • Meet The Review Team
    • Contact Us
    Reading Time
    You are at:Home»Reviews»Younger Readers»Lily in the Mirror

    Lily in the Mirror

    1
    By Admin on August 1, 2016 Younger Readers

    Lily in the mirror

    Paula Hayes, Lily in the Mirror,  Fremantle Press,  1 August 2016,  184pp,  $14.99 (pbk),  ISBN: 9781925163872

    If dictionaries allowed photos, I think Paula Hayes’ Lily would be the picture next to the definition of ‘precocious’. Lily may be a bookworm and an introvert, but her voice and her heart are filled to bursting with the things she wants to tell the world, but doesn’t.

    Lucy is Chinese, but diversity isn’t an overriding theme in the book. Instead, it is presented as something she is, in an otherwise regular family, i.e. a family with which any reader would be familiar – parents and grandparents she loves and siblings she tolerates somewhat.

    In the end, I think what matters most is how Lily brings her family together. While visiting her grandfather, she encounters another Lily, trapped in a mirror in her grandparents’ house. It’s everything she’s ever dreamed of – dark and gothic, and not without a missing finger or two (which are treated with humour so as not to be scary to anyone but her big brother). From that point on, Paula Hayes unfurls Lily’s wildest dreams coming true as she investigates and realises that the Lily in the mirror is part of her family.

    Through this narrative, readers get to see Lily handle her grandmother’s dementia with love and care, see a bulling big brother change and more importantly see grandparents as a big part of the story. Too often it’s easy to give parents and grandparents the barest of characterisations and while Lily’s parents are not a big part of this story, her grandparents are. They are presented as realised characters, with lives and loves before they became grandparents and before her grandmother’s dementia.

    There’s a chance Lily, at 11 and talking in capitals and intialisms, might be too much for readers. I’m in two minds about this because I wonder if there’s a chance some readers might find her hard to relate to, but at the same time, there are those that will enjoy seeing Lily do and say everything they’ve always wanted to do and say.

    Teaching Notes are available on the Fremantle Press website.

    Reviewed by Verushka Byrow

    Booktopia

    Related Posts

    The Ghost Locket

    The Ghost Locket

    Specky Magee

    1 Comment

    1. Melliane on August 3, 2016 6:10 am

      It sounds like a nice one. I don’t read a lot of books like that but maybe! thanks for the review!

      Reply

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    • Themes
    • Curriculum
    Action adventure Airplanes Alphabet Anxiety autism Bullying CBCA Awards Coming of age Dystopian emotions family fantasy friendship grief Historical humour magic Mystery Post apocalyptic Readers Cup reluctant readers school Sci-Fi series of books siblings Sport Starting school Teacher Notes
    ANZAC Australian animals Australian history Biography Culture & Diversity Disabilities First Nations Geography health Humanities mental health Poetry Reconciliation resilience Science STEM Stolen Generation sustainability Wordless books



    Recent Comments
    • Cherie on Elephant Island
    • Patricia Tilton on Freddy the Not-Teddy
    • Jilanne Hoffmann on Freddy the Not-Teddy
    • Penelope Pratley on The Secret of Sapling Green
    • Emily Flint on Walk of the Whales
    Recent Posts
    • It’s Up to Us
    • The Bravest Word
    • The Ghost Locket
    • The Ghost Locket
    • Enough Love?
    Recent Comments
    • Cherie on Elephant Island
    • Patricia Tilton on Freddy the Not-Teddy
    • Jilanne Hoffmann on Freddy the Not-Teddy
    • Penelope Pratley on The Secret of Sapling Green
    • Emily Flint on Walk of the Whales
    © Copyright 2021 The Children’s Book Council of Australia - All rights reserved

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    Posting....